Commentary-Judge Turns Other Cheek;Elevates Judicial System
Last week’s news flash of a prisoner, Bass Webb, spitting in the
face of the District Court Judge made great television footage and
generated much fodder for dinner table gossip.
For those of us who try to humor ourselves in the face of such
events, it brought back memories of the Andy Griffith show when
that fellow named Bass, last name not first, went around Mayberry
throwing rocks through his would-be paramour’s windows and
was even brash enough on one show to throw a rock through the
Courthouse window while an infuriated Barney Fife searched his
front pocket for his single bullet. A composed and judicious Sheriff
Andy Griffith tried to soothe the feathers and search his soul for the
greater good and at one point took the young man, Ernest T. Bass,
to his home to try to teach him proper courting manners.
Bass, all the while exclaiming, “you ain’t seen the last of Ernest
T. Bass.”
We’re not going to suggest that Judge Vanessa Dickson take the
young man who spit in her face into her home in an effort to teach
him the finer points of public etiquette. (Although we have to wonder
how the matter might turn out).
But we do believe that the import of this temporary news flash
pales in significance to the much greater good which the Judge,
perhaps unwittingly, has bestowed upon the judicial system by her
measured and judicious response.
Many people who have little exposure to the Court system may
be unaware of the day to day trials and tribulations those in the
system deal with.
Most people who come before a court do so because they have
a problem that hasn’t been resolved.
They may be a victim who has been injured or a family member
of a victim who has felt the pain of seeing a loved one injured or
killed. They may be a witness to something, usually bad, that has
occurred in their presence. They may be a person charged with a
crime. Among those charged with crimes there may be those that
are truly “bad guys”, but there are also those that have problems
of their own, emotional or otherwise. Then, of course, there are
those that are innocent but have nonetheless been jailed or deprived
of their rights.(The “innocence project” has with DNA proof freed
over 200 innocent people in the last few years that were erroneously
convicted by Courts and who have in some cases served many,
many years for a crime it has been proven they did not commit.)
A few things can be said for certain.
1 Emotions often run high and people, good and bad, rich
and poor, guilty or innocent have made bad choices or found themselves in bad situations.
2. No matter the outcome, when one “case” or problem is
solved, you can be virtually assured that next week there will be
more to come to take its place.
Judges sit atop a system that is imperfect. Under the black robe
they wear they are human beings, too, complete with all the frailties
and emotions that everyone else has, and they do make mistakes.
The real import of the behavioral malfunction in court last week
we think is a positive one.
We think that Judge Dickson’s conduct which was seen on televised
clips exemplified the very essence of what judicial conduct
should be. From public comments we’ve heard since the incident,
there is, in fact, an elevated sense of respect for the Court on account
of her line of fire display of judicial temperament. Judicial
temperament, is a commodity not possessed by everyone and one
that is certainly not taught in law schools. (Although, the Andy
Griffith show may take a pretty good whack at it.)
Put in very simple terms our whole judicial system has to be
based on the notion that the courtroom, however imperfect, is a better
way to resolve differences than the barroom, Although barroom
justice may have been more swift, it would not likely have allowed
for the kind of “lead by example” judicial temperament displayed
by Judge Dickson last week.
We’ve come along way from Jesus’ sermon on the Mount
wherein He enjoined His followers: “If someone strikes you on the
right cheek, turn to him the other also.”
But we do think that good behavior is best taught by example
and in this regard, the Judge ‘hit the ball out of the park’ by firmly
but fairly dealing with this infuriating situation.
This judge on this day in our opinion by her graceful conduct
elevated respect for the Court system and served as an example of
what our court systems should stand for.